When to Disobey: Moral Autonomy in the Military

This article explores the complex question of when a military officer should disobey orders, even legal ones. The author argues that blind obedience is insufficient and that officers possess a moral autonomy stemming from their oath to the Constitution and their responsibility to their subordinates. Using historical examples and personal anecdotes, the author contends that officers have an obligation to challenge illegal or ethically questionable orders, even at the risk of career repercussions. The piece criticizes a lack of Congressional oversight of military actions and the resulting lack of public accountability.